Published January 10, 2008  |  A A A
SmartMoney Magazine by Angie C. Marek (Author Archive)

Peddling Pills

ON A RECENT EVENING at dusk, Josie Salcedo-Guzman, a tall mom in a crisp navy and lime green pantsuit, walks briskly into the office of Dr. Larry Neuman in the Washington Heights neighborhood of Manhattan. The office, a clinic that sees 200 patients a day at its busiest, is experiencing a rare moment of quiet, and Neuman bounds into the lobby, kisses Salcedo-Guzman on both cheeks and brings her into the back. They briefly reminisce about a recent dinner they had at Buddakan, New York's hot Pan-Asian restaurant of the moment. Salcedo-Guzman gives Neuman a token of thanks: personalized sign-in sheets he can put in the waiting room, his practice's name and address embossed on top.

But then it's on to business. With clinical precision, Salcedo-Guzman reaches into her bag for a blue box the size of a long ladies wallet. She flips it open to reveal what she calls "a very exciting educational tool" — a tiny illustration of a set of lungs with airways shaped like tree branches, colored cherry red to show inflammation. "This is what the lungs look like when you have asthma, even if you're symptom-free," she enthusiastically explains. She pulls a cardboard tab to reveal a second illustration, this time of airways colored a faint, healthy pink. "But if you take a daily maintenance medication, your lungs can look like this." The box includes a quiz that can gauge the severity of someone's asthma; a booklet on the disease; and most important, several $20-off vouchers for Symbicort, a new asthma medication made by Salcedo-Guzman's employer, AstraZeneca. She asks Neuman to give the packet "to just that one person" whose symptoms aren't yet under control. "You guys are so creative," he says, playfully arching his reddish eyebrows. "Can I hold it?" She hands the box across the table. "Tenderly, please," she says, chuckling, "like a baby."

For an inside look at how drug reps operate and how some doctors make money from drug companies, see the February issue of SmartMoney magazine, on newsstands now.

Welcome to the pharmaceutical sales pitch, 21st-century edition. Salcedo-Guzman is, of course, a drug-sales rep, and though most patients have no way of knowing it, a small army of people just like her are tugging at the lab coats of their doctors. Not long ago reformers thought they'd curbed this coziness between doctors and the Willy Lomans of Big Pharma, as physicians and drug companies alike instituted a widely publicized ethics crackdown. But with the drug industry facing the loss of more than $60 billion a year in sales to competition from generics, companies in recent years have been quietly inflating the ranks of these well-dressed professionals, with their suitcases full of samples. There were 35,000 reps in 1995, but the number is close to 100,000 today, according to the consultancy the Hay Group. Put another way, there's one office-based physician for every 975 Americans — and roughly one drug rep for every three of those physicians.

Once they arrive at the doctor's office, these road warriors use different methods to wield their influence, and the trinket is as powerful as the junket. The new rules bar lavish, Gordon Gekko-era gifts like opera boxes and airline tickets, but pharmaceutical companies are gambling that a blizzard of constant attention and small freebies can be more effective than big gestures when it comes to promoting their products. Almost all "detailers," as reps are known, leave behind a trail of persuasive literature and giveaways. Everything from hand sanitizers to wall clocks to computer memory sticks have been emblazoned with drug logos and given to physicians, along with roughly $16 billion annually in free drug samples. Reps also provide enough free lunches and dinner lecture programs to doctors and their staffs that at least one national Web site has sprung up to help them order all the take-out food.

1
2
3
4
Next
Find More Articles About: Personal Finance, General, Health Care
User Comments
Posted by: bhattara

Smart Money really made this a one sided debate. First of all life is not so black and white. As an academic physician, we use pharma companies to help build science, assist patients, and educate our colleagues. We do not have all the cures for cancer, manage diabetes, and address psychiatric illness.
I think Smart Money does not have an understanding complex issues regarding our medical care.
By the way pharm companies do not just offer dinners. All evening programs are tied with educational activity and spouses are not able to come
Raj Bhattacharya MD

Posted by: mrbkelly

Sure wish the press would publish a story about the good that pharmaceutical companies do for the improvement of patients' health. What about providing new therapies to patients that otherwise had no option in the past. For instance, What if big pharma never researched and developed statin drugs such as Zocor and Lipitor--- how many people would be living with cholesterol levels and tehrfore at a higher risk of heart attack, stroke or death?

There are salespeople in every industry. Why should drug companies not have the same opportunity to promote their products features and benefits?

Posted by: Pharmarep

I recommend fact checking before publishing an article. There is in fact a head to head trial comparing Symbicort to Advair. It is called the Atlantis trial.

As well, it would have been more appropriate to follow a representative that actually carried a drug that also had a generic for purposes of your argument. You failed to mention that for many medicines like Symbicort and Advair there is not a generic medicine available for patients. In this circumstance, the pharma rep like the one you shadowed becomes the only patient advocate to educate the physician on the medicine and its costs.

Posted by: jzasaa

I have worked as a pharmacist for over 30 years; I have NEVER know ANY individual pharmacist to get ANY additional compensation for filling generics. We fill generics only to save patients money. I would NEVER dispense a generic if I felt it was inferior to the brand name. My patient always come FIRST. Unlike doctors, I do not get any dinners or lunches from drug reps. In fact, my company does not allow drug reps to visit pharmacies. I am here for my patients only.

Posted by: jzasaa

Generics are identical to brand name medications. In fact, the same company sometimes makes the generic and brand name medication. For example, the generic Lotrel, is identical to the brand name. In fact, the brand name 'Lotrel' is stamped on the generic medication's capsule. The company that markets the generic is owned by the company that makes the brand name. A generic medication is clincal the same as the brand name medication. Brand name drug companies try to misguide people to make more money.

Advertisements